Muttontown, NY Real Estate

Muttontown NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Muttontown NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Muttontown: $2,688,094  County Average: $1,128,428

Average Taxes in Muttontown: $41,083  County Average: $21,000

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Muttontown: $393  County Average: $356

Average Walkscore in Muttontown: 21  County Average: 50

Average Year Built in Muttontown: 1979  County Average: 1958

Average Days on Website in Muttontown: 132  County Average: 101

Muttontown NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhoods in Muttontown NY

Oyster Bay

Areas in Muttontown NY

Lions Crest Muttontown Knolls Stone Hill
The Hollows

Most Popular Listing

Popular Muttontown Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Muttontown Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Muttontown Real Estate


Listings in Muttontown

Classic brick/shingle 5 bd/3.5 bt colonial in lions crest community with communal tennis court...

Muttontown. your dream home is your dream...

French chateau style brick colonial with incredible architectural details...

thinking of building your dream home? here's the spot to do it! set on 1.9 acres of plush mutt...

thinking of building your dream home? here's the spot to do it. set on 1.9 acres of plush mutt...

Ne luxurious perfectly located mid block jewel of Muttontown. open floor pl...

mint spacious sprawling ranch home w/beautiful walkout lower level nestled on 2 wooded acres in prestigious enclave the hollows of Muttontown offers tremendous value. light bright ...

best location in pen mor estates behind a cul-de-sac with private gates and unquestionably one of the most beautiful settings in the village of Muttontown and all of the north shore on long island. resort style country...

Almost completely original, but maintained french norman from1929...

o'connor for john f. bermingham, a coal baron & former mayor of Muttontown. this gold coast manor was meticulously restored in 2004 to its...

Beautifully designed stone and shingle traditional home completely renovated in 2010...

E situated on 4.77 beautiful and private acres in Muttontown. the southern...

Better than new! no detail spared in this masterpiece residence, with its own fabulous pool & pool house...

Approx.4634 sq foot includes gar but not basement...

A colonial home features 4 bdrms, 2.5 baths(1 in master)+bonus rm...

Incredible opportunity to own a great location in the hollows...

Muttontown. build your dream home! all utilities are disconnected...

Stone hill at Muttontown custom colonial "to be" built in a culdesac, wonderful moldings and millwork, beautiful to be built custom colonial,gourmet kitchen & lavish baths, stone hill luxury lifestyle community, 24 hr security,clubhouse pool/gym/tennis, full ground maintenance & snow removal included, taxes not fully assessed approx hoa $775...

Spectacular &pristine classic two story entry brick colonial with top of the line amenities...

Muttontown stone hill gated community. rare! master on the main floor with private loft...

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

Exit Alliance Realty
164-13 Hillside Avenue
Jamaica Hills, NY